A problem with the ghost genre, is that all has been done to
death. The rattling doorknob, the dog that doesn't like certain people, the
sudden movement and sound to create a shriek and a gasp for the audience etc.
Del Toro doesn't really hit a nerve with any of this, as you could expect.
Furthermore it's hard to create a notion of something horrible, using small
hints throughout the film, when you show the apparition twice early on.
The casting pretty much centres around Wasikowski and
Hiddlestone, with a dash of an extremely boring Jessica Chastain. The former
have a good chemistry, and particularly Hiddlestone makes the best out of his
part, as his character is the only one with layers. The problem with not lining
up a stronger ensemble is of course that you have fewer strings, and
furthermore that you rely too much on your stars. The biggest drawback though,
is that the director fails to pay adequate attention to the other characters.
And with his extreme focus on costumes and scenography, Del Toro falls into
that trap as well.
Furthermore, Del Toro fails in the art of subtlety, using too broad a brush for many of his "little" omens. The clues are easy for all to see, thus making the omens and ghosts moot. And when it comes to the violence, it's brutal in a Tarantinoesque way. But not in any way as entertaining.
The music by Fernando Velázquez is one of the more stunning
scores of this year, and worthy of a point in itself. Del Toro doesn't make the
best use of it, relying too heavily on the main theme, even where it does not
really fit in. And often not using it at all. But you really should take the
time to listen to it on its own.
2/10